Hoskins admits Southern Kings Super15 defeat

South African rugby boss Oregan Hoskins has all but given up on South Africa having the extra team when Super Rugby expands to a Super 15 in 2011 but still holds hope that his South African players will be able to play for the new Melbourne team.

SANZAR are expected to announce before the end of next month that the new Super 15 team will be based in Melbourne or Port Elizabeth but Hoskins has admitted to the Australian that it is hugely unlikely that his team will win the vote.

For the Southern Kings team to be named as the new Super 15  team all three parties would have to agree but South Africa appear to be resigned to losing the vote.

“We’re outvoted anyway, we always are,” Hoskins told The Australian.

Hoskins was then asked if he was implying that Australia and New Zealand always ganged up on South Africa in crucial SANZAR votes, Hoskins replied with a laugh: “Oh, absolutely! You know that.”

It is highly unlikely that New Zealand would vote for South Africa as it would mean that their team would spend an extended period of time in South Africa when the teams do go on tour. The amount of travel involved would be greatly increased if the team were based in South Africa in contrast to Australia.

It has already been agreed that the new Super 15 franchise will be required to play out of the Australian conference, but even Hoskins was at a loss to explain how the Kings would fit into a round-robin series against the Waratahs, Brumbies , Reds and Western Force.

The functionality of having a foreign team based in what was meant to be a local conference baffles the mind.

Would, for instance, the Australian teams be required to travel to South Africa for some matches or would the Kings be based in Australia for the conference stage of the tournament?

“I really haven’t looked at it very closely, but I just thought it was possible they could spend time in both countries … maybe even more time in Australia, seeing they are playing in the Australian conference,” said Hoskins.

“But I’m not sure if this whole idea will get past first base anyway, because Australia is keen on having its own team in the competition.

“I haven’t given up. I thought we might actually be able to have a combined franchise.”

The Australian put to Hoskins that a combined franchise would not work and he said, “At first glance, it might not but we need to explore the possibility of thinking outside the box and stop thinking tribalistically.”

However when Hoskins was asked whether he would back the idea of Kings players joining the Melbourne Super Rugby team. “Absolutely,” Hoskins said.

“That possibility exists. We’re open to that. Certainly our players are.” which suggests that Hoskins has discussed the seemingly inevitable franchise loss to Australia with member of the Southern Kings.

“It would still give them the opportunity to play Super rugby, even if they are based in Melbourne for that season.”

ARU chief executive John O’Neill has proposed the potential relaxation of rules within SANZAR that would allow Australian, New Zealand and South African players to move freely within the SANZAR alliance and still be eligible to play for their country and Hoskins seems to be behind this idea so if South African players do end up playing in Melbourne they could still be eligible to play for the Springboks.

The same would apply to New Zealand’s players if the rules were relaxed so Melbourne could make someone like Dan Carter an offer to play offshore and

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.